McClatchy Newspapers (MCT)
Gradual" self-tanning lotions promise to deliver plenty of hydration as well as a touch of sun. And almost every brand of moisturizer has one in its line now.
We tested 10 of the newest, reformulated or repackaged ones on shelves this spring. Here are the three that worked the best:
OUR TOP THREE PERFORMERS
Neutrogena Summer Glow
(For fair skin tones; $9.79 for 6.7 ounces at CVS)
Claim: Gives a light, natural glow, plus UV protection
Sunscreen? Yes, SPF 20
Instructions: Use daily; allow several minutes to dry before dressing.
Appearance/smell: White and creamy, light but not runny; soapy and subtle scent
Good points: Saw results within two applications. Easy to control the amount of "tan" as results are gradual, not immediate and obvious.
Bad points: A bit more orange than a natural tan
Noticed results: After two uses, it took my legs from "scary white" to "acceptable for public viewing."
Results lasted: Several days
(For light to medium skin tones; $7.99 for 8.4 ounces at Ulta)
Claim: Builds a healthy glow in five days, improves skin firmness, provides lasting moisture
Instructions: Apply liberally; avoid contact with clothes until lotion is absorbed
Appearance/smell: White and creamy, but a little runny; pleasant, light citrus fragrance
Good points: Skin really did "glow" without turning orange
Bad points: Because it's thin, it's easy to apply too much. I did, and ended up wiping some off with a towel.
Noticed results: After two applications (two days)
Results lasted: Until about two days after I stopped using it
(For medium/dark skin tones; $6.99 for 6.7 ounces at SuperTarget)
Claim: "Wake up with a sun-kissed glow."
Instructions: Apply before bedtime. Leave it on for at least 15 minutes before lying on sheets or putting on pajamas.
Appearance/smell: Thick, smooth and a good, solid bronze color; a strong but pleasant chamomile-lavender scent
Good points: As advertised, the results were immediate and a good match to my natural caramel skin color.
Bad points: I tan easily _ as do most with darker complexions _ so it's not a product I would use often.
Noticed results: The next morning
Results lasted: Four or five days
ADVICE FROM A DERMATOLOGIST
Dr. James McCarty, of Southwest Cosmetic Dermatology Associates in Fort Worth, Texas, answered some burning questions about self-tanning lotions.
Q: How do gradual self-tanning moisturizers work?
A: All self-tanners have a chemical in them called dihydroxyacetone (DHA), which causes a chemical reaction with the top layer of the skin and produces a darker color. A lower concentration of DHA (as in these products) causes a slower color change.
Q: Can anyone use them?
A: There's no such thing as a product no one has reacted to ... but I have not personally seen anyone who ever had a reaction to these things. If you have certain kinds of growths that absorb DHA, it can turn growths darker. But if you stop using the product, (the darkness) will go away.
Q: How long can you use one bottle or tube?
A: Follow the expiration date on the label like you would any other product. Like anything else, these eventually go bad.
Q: Most of these moisturizers don't contain sunscreen. Should you apply sunscreen before or after you use a self-tan lotion?
A: It doesn't matter whether you apply sunscreen before or after these moisturizers; the important thing is to use it. Look for a sunscreen that protects against the sun's UVA and UVB rays.
Others we tested:
—L'Oreal Sublime Glow for fair skin tones
—Jergens Natural Glow Daily Moisturizer for medium/tan skin tones
—Banana Boat EveryDay Glow SunDial Self-Tanning Moisturizer for lighter skin tones
—Bath & Body Works True Blue Spa Glow & Steady Daily Moisturizer For Body
—Vaseline Healthy Body Glow for medium skin tones
—St. Ives Healthy Brilliance Renew & Glow for fair to medium skin tones
—Aveeno Continuous Radiance Moisturizing Lotion for all skin tones
(McClatchy Newspapers correspondents Todd Camp, Felicia Smith and Diana Andro contributed to this report.)
(c) 2007, Fort Worth Star-Telegram.
Visit the Star-Telegram on the World Wide Web at http://www.star-telegram.com.
Distributed by McClatchy-Tribune Information Services.